Talk:Malik Ibrahim Baya

Review 1

The author is appreciated for writing about one of the undiscovered Sufis. It is appreciated that the author has written completely original content that is plagiarism-free. But it is very short—just 855 words. Per the publication's guidelines, all the paid articles must be at least 1000 words, whereas there is no higher limit for articles here. If the author thinks, a long article is needed, they should go for it. There is scope for improvement where the author can expand the article by using scholarly papers, books, and journals to make their research more impactful. There are available books and papers that should be used. The context providing information about his Urs festival in detail, his military career, tabligh, and his Sufi career and explaining why he should be included on this website would be helpful. Also, the primary source (interview by Umar Ashraf of Khadim, Md. Alauddin) mentioned below claims the saint was from Persia, not Ghazni, so it should be corrected. I have mentioned a few scholarly works below mentioning the subject. Both primary and secondary sources should be used for a good research paper. Peer reviƐwer (talk) 19:04, 24 May 2024 (UTC)

• Biographical Encyclopaedia of Sufis: South Asia - Page 160 N. Hanif · 2000.
• Sufis of India, Pakistan and Bangladesh, Volume 1 2002.
•  https://youtu.be/LxqQO7MTTJ0?feature=shared

His father was from Ghazni mentioned in old urdu books, but a book named Riyazul Nayeem written by Muhammad Nayeem published in 1950s changed the whole scene regarding his ancestors and other information. That book isn’t Mustanad, according to many Sunni sufi scholars. And about the interview of Khadim uploaded by Muhamamd Umar Ashraf, is useless. Khadim is totally against the history, he just told the story of the theft at Dargah in previous years. I’ll try to expand it, In Sha Allah. QuadriSyedSahab (talk) 19:46, 24 May 2024 (UTC)

QuadriSyedSahab You should cite those old Urdu books to back up your claims then. Peer reviƐwer (talk) 06:09, 25 May 2024 (UTC)

Peer reviƐwer, I'm done with all references and information. Kindly have a look. QuadriSyedSahab (talk) 15:49, 25 May 2024 (UTC)

Review 2

• Please add Death years of the historical personality. Also add the sources for unreferenced claims wherever necesssary. 12:24, 27 May 2024 (UTC)

All claims are from the books I already used as references, all are present in those books. I also used some references (websites) kindly have a look there. I’ll add (birth-death) of the historical figures ASAP. Jazak Allah QuadriSyedSahab (talk) 12:29, 27 May 2024 (UTC)